How to Nail Anya Forger Cosplay Makeup Like a Total Pro

Introduction

Anya cosplay makeup isn’t just about slapping on some pink eyeshadow and calling it a day. I’ve been doing cosplay for a few years now, and let me tell you—getting Anya’s look right takes some thought. She’s got this adorable, innocent vibe mixed with those hilariously dramatic expressions that make Spy x Family so addictive. And honestly? Her makeup is deceptively simple, but there’s a bunch of little tricks that’ll take your Anya cosplay from “meh” to “wait, are you actually her?” I’m gonna walk you through everything I’ve learned about nailing this look. From her big green eyes to that ridiculously cute smile, we’re covering it all. No fluff, no boring theory—just real, actionable steps that’ll help you look like the world’s most telepathic (and peanut-obsessed) kid. Let’s get into it.

A young cosplayer with a pastel pink wig and side ponytails applies emerald green eyeshadow in a sunlit bedroom mirror, surrounded by makeup brushes and cosplay reference images, with golden hour lighting casting a warm glow on their fair skin and a soft pink blush palette in view.

Understanding Anya’s Character Design First

Before we dive into the actual makeup, you gotta understand what makes Anya… well, Anya. Her whole look is built around being this innocent, expressive little girl who secretly reads minds and gets into the most chaotic situations.

Key visual elements:
  • Emerald green eyes that are huge and expressive
  • Pink hair (bubblegum pink, not hot pink)
  • Fair, porcelain-like skin
  • Small, delicate facial features
  • That goofy grin she’s famous for
  • Black and yellow horn accessories (sometimes gold)

The thing is, Anya’s design is pretty minimalistic compared to other anime characters. She doesn’t have crazy markings or over-the-top features. But that simplicity is exactly why getting the details right matters so much. One thing I learned the hard way? Her expression does half the work. You can have perfect makeup, but if you’re not channeling that playful, slightly mischievous energy, it won’t feel like Anya.

Close-up of a cosplay makeup transformation highlighting the application of white waterline eyeliner and green circle lenses, featuring soft diffused lighting that showcases the shift from natural skin to anime-inspired makeup at a professional makeup station with precise brushes and character sketches, in a neutral beige and soft pink color palette.

Prepping Your Skin for That Porcelain Anime Look

Okay, so first things first—skin prep. Anime characters always have that super smooth, almost doll-like complexion. And Anya’s no exception. Start with a good primer to smooth out your skin texture. I like using something that’s a bit blurring because it hides pores and gives you that flat, cartoon-ish finish. Then, you’re gonna want a full-coverage foundation that matches a fair skin tone. Even if you’re naturally darker, cosplay is about transforming into the character, so don’t be afraid to go lighter (just blend down your neck so there’s no harsh line).

Steps I always follow:
  • Cleanse and moisturize first (duh)
  • Apply a pore-filling primer
  • Use a beauty sponge to blend foundation evenly
  • Set with a translucent powder to avoid any shine

Anime skin doesn’t have dimension the way real skin does. So you’re actually gonna skip contouring for now. Weird, right? But trust me, flat and matte is what you’re going for here.

A young female cosplayer arranges black and gold horn accessories on a pink wig in a minimalist studio with a clean white backdrop, illuminated by natural window light. Makeup tools and reference images are subtly arranged around her, capturing the preparatory moments before she embodies her character.

Creating Anya’s Signature Big Green Eyes

This is where the magic happens. Anya’s eyes are HUGE, and they’re this beautiful emerald green that just pops. Getting that right is honestly the most important part of the whole look.

Here’s my process:

Start by using a white or nude eyeliner on your waterline. This instantly makes your eyes look bigger. Then, grab some green circle lenses if you can. They’re honestly game-changers for anime cosplay. Make sure they’re safe and from a reputable seller though—your eyes aren’t worth risking.

Next up: eyeshadow. Use a light, shimmery green on your lids. Nothing too dark or dramatic. Anya’s a kid, so the makeup should look soft and innocent. Blend a slightly darker green into your crease for a bit of depth, but keep it subtle.

Eyeliner technique:
  • Use black liquid eyeliner to create a slightly extended wing
  • Keep the line thin—thick liner will age the look
  • Add a small flick at the outer corner, but don’t go overboard
  • Some cosplayers add a tiny white dot in the inner corner for that anime sparkle effect
Lower lash line:

Draw individual lashes under your eyes with a thin brush and black eyeliner. Sounds weird, but it mimics that anime style where lower lashes are super defined. Just do 3-4 little strokes on each eye. Don’t go crazy or you’ll look like a spider.

False lashes:

You NEED these for Anya. Go for lashes that are long but not too thick or dramatic. Natural-looking falsies with length work best. Apply them carefully, and if you wanna go the extra mile, add a second smaller set on the outer corners for that doe-eyed effect.

Dramatic overhead view of a well-organized cosplay makeup layout featuring green eyeshadow palettes, false eyelashes, soft pink blush, and precision makeup brushes on a white surface, illuminated by golden hour sunlight casting soft shadows.

Eyebrows That Actually Look Like Anya’s

Anya’s eyebrows are pretty straight and soft. Not super arched like a lot of female characters. If your brows are naturally dark or shaped differently, you might need to lighten or reshape them. I usually use a glue stick (yeah, really) to flatten my natural brows, then apply foundation over them. Then I redraw them using a light brown eyebrow pencil or powder. Keep them straight across, slightly thick, and positioned a bit higher than your natural brow line. This gives that youthful, innocent look. Don’t make them too perfect though. Anya’s a kid, not a supermodel. A little imperfection actually helps sell the character.

A cosplayer practicing Anya Forger's expressions in a softly lit bedroom mirror, wearing emerald green contacts and a pastel pink wig, showcasing playful and mischievous character moments.

Blush and That Adorable Childlike Flush

Anya always has this cute, rosy-cheeked thing going on. It’s subtle but super important for capturing her youthful vibe. Use a soft pink blush and apply it to the apples of your cheeks. Not along your cheekbones like regular makeup—literally on the roundest part of your cheeks. Smile and find where they puff up, that’s where the blush goes. Blend it upward slightly toward your temples, but keep it soft and diffused. You can also add a tiny bit on the bridge of your nose for that extra cuteness factor. Some cosplayers even put a touch on their chin, but that’s optional

Pin This Now to Remember It Later
Pin This

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top