Why Most “Scary” Costumes Just Don’t Hit Right
Contents
Here’s the thing nobody tells you.
Most store-bought scary costumes look cheap because they are cheap. That plastic mask from the big box store? Everyone’s seen it a hundred times. The secret to a truly scary costume isn’t always about spending more money. It’s about committing to the look and adding those small details that make people do a double-take.
I’ve seen someone absolutely nail a creepy character with stuff from their closet and some face paint, while someone else spent $200 and looked like they were wearing a garbage bag. The difference was in the effort and the execution.
Classic Horror Movie Characters That Never Get Old
Pennywise From IT – The Clown That Ruined Birthday Parties
This one’s been huge ever since the newer IT movies came out. And honestly, it’s scary because clowns are already unsettling to a lot of people.
Here’s what you need for a solid Pennywise look:
- Red and white face paint (don’t skimp on this – good Halloween face paint makes all the difference)
- A striped red and white costume (you can make this with fabric or buy it pre-made)
- Bright red wig or spray your hair red
- Yellow contacts if you really want to commit
- Red balloon as a prop
The makeup is where most people mess up. You need that exaggerated smile and those red lines coming down from the mouth. Watch a YouTube tutorial the day before so you’re not panicking an hour before the party. I tried winging it once and ended up looking like a sad birthday clown instead of a terrifying sewer demon.
Ghostface From Scream – The Last-Minute Lifesaver
This is my go-to recommendation for anyone who texts me three days before Halloween asking for help.
You literally need two things:
- Black hooded cape or robe
- White Ghostface mask
That’s it. You can find both at basically any Halloween store or order a Ghostface costume set online and have it shipped fast. The reason this works so well is because it’s ICONIC. Everyone knows Ghostface, and that mask is genuinely creepy when someone’s wearing it and not talking.
Pro tip: Don’t talk much when you’re wearing it. Just stand there. The silence makes it way scarier.
Other Movie Monsters Worth Your Time
Pinhead from Hellraiser is underrated in my opinion. If you can handle some prosthetic work or you’re good with makeup, this costume will absolutely disturb people. The grid pattern on the face and those pins sticking out? Nightmare fuel.
Regan from The Exorcist works great if you’re willing to do the possessed look. Pale makeup, dark circles under the eyes, maybe some fake vomit for effect. Carrying around a Ouija board really sells it too.
Samara from The Ring is perfect if you’ve got long dark hair. Just get a dirty white nightgown, mess up your hair so it covers your face, and move really slowly and creepy-like. Bonus points if you randomly crawl out of somewhere during the party.
Supernatural and Gothic Costumes That’ll Give People Chills
Weeping Angels – The Costume That Requires Commitment
This one’s from Doctor Who, and if you do it right, it’s TERRIFYING. Weeping Angels are these stone statues that only move when you’re not looking at them.
Here’s how to pull it off:
- Gray body paint (and I mean FULL body – face, neck, hands, everything exposed)
- Gray or stone-colored draped fabric (think toga-style but creepy)
- White or very pale wig if your hair isn’t already light
- Gray body paint makeup that won’t rub off on everything
The key is staying STILL when people look at you. Then moving slightly when they look away. It freaks people out because it’s unexpected and plays with their heads. I saw someone do this at a party once and she literally made someone scream.
Woman in Black – Simple But Effective
This is one of those costumes that seems too simple to work, but trust me, it does.
You need:
- Black dress (long, Victorian-style if possible)
- Black veil or black fabric to drape over your head
- White face paint
- Candlestick or lantern as a prop
The slow, haunting movements are what sell this costume. Don’t smile, don’t break character, just glide around looking tragic and creepy.
Grim Reaper – A Classic For a Reason
Yeah, it’s been done a million times. But a GOOD Grim Reaper costume still works. You just need a quality black hooded cloak (not the cheap shiny one) and a decent scythe prop. The face is what matters here – either go full skeleton makeup or keep your face shadowed under the hood so people can barely see you. That mystery is what makes it unsettling.
